Previously in The Story That Won’t Die - leading to a precise definition of cowardice…. you will find passages from Josh Marshall’s Talking Points Memo where Marshall makes a brief argument about
George Bush, asserting he is a specific kind of coward, a moral coward.
Marshall elaborates a bit a day later (Tuesday,
August 24, 2004) and gives us this, and the excerpt here is only a taste. The emphases in bold are mine.
I’m not sure this is good campaign advice
for John Kerry.
The current debate about these two men's military service has put the spotlight on physical courage.
But that really is a side issue in this campaign, if we're talking substance. The real issue isn't physical bravery but moral
President Bush is an exemplar of that quality in spades. And it cuts directly to his failures as president.
Forget about thirty years ago, just think about the last three years.
Before proceeding on to that, one other point
about the two men's service. On the balance sheet of moral bravery, as opposed to physical bravery, the two men are about
as far apart as you can be on Vietnam. On the one hand you have Kerry, who already had doubts about whether we should be
fighting in Vietnam before he went, and put his life on the line anyway. On the other hand, you have George W. Bush who supported
the war, which means he believed the goal was worth the cost in American lives. Only, not his life. He believed others should
go; just not him. It's the story of his life.
That is almost the definition of moral cowardice.
a more immediate sense of what physical bravery and cowardice are. In fact, when we speak of bravery and cowardice, the physical
variety is almost always what we're talking about. It's whether or not you can charge an enemy position while you're be fired
at. It's whether you're immobilized by the fear of death.
Moral cowardice is more complex. A moral coward is someone
who lacks the courage to tell the truth, to accept responsibility, to demand accountability, to do what's right when it's
not the easy thing to do, to clean up his or her own messes. Perhaps we could say that moral bravery is having both the
courage of your convictions as well as the courage of your misdeeds.
As I've been saying here for the last couple
days, the issue isn't that Bush ducked service in Vietnam. It's that he tries to smear other people's meritorious service
without taking responsibility for what he's doing. He gets other people to do his dirty work for him.
The key for the Kerry campaign to make is that the president's moral cowardice is why we're now bogged down in Iraq.
It's a key reason why almost a thousand Americans have died there. President Bush has set the tone for this administration
and his moral cowardice permeates it.
Consider only the most obvious examples.
The president didn't think
he could convince the public of the merits of his reasons for going to war. So he lied to them. He greatly exaggerated what
was thought to be the evidence of weapons of mass destruction and completely manufactured a connection between Iraq and al
Qaida. He couldn't get the country behind him on the up-and-up. So he took the easy way out; he took a shortcut; he deceived
them. And now the country is paying a terrible price for it.
He and his advisors knew that if they leveled with the public
about the costs of war -- in dollars, years, soldiers -- he'd have a very hard time convincing them. So he didn't level with
them. He took the easy way out.
The sort of forward planning that would have made a big difference in post-war Iraq
was scuttled or attacked because it would make the job of selling the war harder. Those who sounded the alarm had their careers
Once we were in Iraq and it was clear that we had been wrong about the weapons of mass destruction -- a
judgment that's been clear for more than a year -- he wouldn't admit it. And he still hasn't. A year and a half after we invaded
Iraq and he still can't level with the American people about this. He still relies on his vice president to try to
fool people into thinking Hussein was tied to al Qaida and the 9/11 attacks.
More importantly, once it became clear
that the president's plans for post-war Iraq were producing poor results, he refused to shift policy or to reshuffle his team.
He refused to demand accountability from his own team because of how it would have reflected on him. He's preferred to continue
on with demonstrably failed policies because to do otherwise would be to admit he'd made a mistake and open himself to all
the political fall-out that entails. And that's not something he's willing to do.
The stubborn refusal ever to
change course, which the president tries to pass off as a sign of leadership or devotion to principle, is actually an example
of his cowardice.
For the same reasons, he runs from soldiers' funerals like they were burying victims of the
plague -- because it's the easy way out. If there's a problem, he denies it or finds someone else to take the fall for him.
Everyone has these tendencies in their measure. No one is perfect. But they define George W. Bush.
sort of moral cowardice that led him to support the Vietnam war but decide it wasn't for him, run companies into the ground
and let others pay the bill, play gutter politics but run for the hills when someone asks him to say it to their face, those
are the same qualities that led the president to lie the country into war, fail to prepare for the aftermath and then refuse
to take responsibility for any of it when the bill started to come due.
That's the argument John Kerry needs to be
making. And he needs to make it right now.
All very well argued, but were John Kerry to stand in front of a national audience and say
this - “President Bush. Be a man. Take responsibility for what you do, and what you have done. Grow
up.” – Kerry would change no voters’ minds.
Almost all votes have made up their minds already.
And half the country likes this child bully who can sucker-punch the skinny, brainy wimp and get away with it. Hey,
it is entertaining - and plays to the secret fantasy of so many who feel life, and brainy wimps who get along with the French,
have treated them unfairly and mocked their lack of education and their simple incurious values and tell them life is complicated
when it really isn’t.
I don’t think this will fly.